Copyright 2024 All Rights Reserved.

June 18, 2024

Loser of Mayoral Race Sues Winner, Media Entity, and Others –

By John Kraft & Kirk Allen

On October 26, 2021

Poplar Grove, IL. (ECWd) –

RMS Insurance Services, Flanders Insurance Agency, and Owen Costanza (former Village President of Poplar Grove who lost the most recent Mayoral election) filed a lawsuit naming the current Village President of Poplar Grove, Donald Sattler, and three others as Defendants.

Plaintiff is asking for combined judgments in excess of $250,000.00.

The suit alleges, among others:

  • Defendant SATTLER has made statements, created and circulated written material in person and on line to members of the public regarding OWEN that are untrue, deceptive, misleading and inflammatory, including, without limitation, a widely-disseminated flyer falsely attributing a “criminal record” to OWEN and falsely accusing him of fraudulent and criminal acts and being a “repeat criminal,” in violation of Illinois Statutes. See EXHIBIT 1 – False Flyer, attached hereto
  • SATTLER has repeatedly posted statements on third party Facebook pages regarding OWEN that are untrue, deceptive, misleading and inflammatory
  • SATTLER publicly distributed certain of the Sattler Harassment, including without limitation, the EXHIBIT 1 – False Flyer, throughout local businesses in Poplar Grove, personally posting copies of the EXHIBIT 1 – False Flyer on the doors, walls, and windows of businesses, including, without limitation, those of Plaintiffs’ current and prospective clients and customers, throughout the Village.

From amongst the 17-Count Complaint:

  • Tortious interference with prospective business advantage
  • Tortious interference with contract
  • Civil conspiracy to tortuously interfere with Plaintiff’s contracts with existing customers, tortuously interfere with Plaintiff’s prospective business advantage, and to damage and injure Plaintiff’s business and reputations in the community
  • Defamation
  • Business defamation under Illinois common law

The “False Flyer

In the alleged “False Flyer” are the following statements, with our comments and public records after each statement:

My Opponents Criminal record Is:

    • 1995 Pleads guilty to filing false report to Boone County 
      • Court records indicate Costanza did in fact enter a guilty plea on June 27, 1996. The Court later entered a “withhold judgment/court supervision” disposition for the case
    • 1999 Terminated from Liberty Insurance for Fraud Misrepresentation
      • Public records obtained from the State of Wisconsin indicate Costanza was terminated under Codes 15 and 17, which identify as “fraud” and “misrepresentation” according to the state. The last page is a short statement on the actual reason(s) for termination as allegedly reported by the employer.
    • 1999 Pleads guilty to writing bad check in Boone County
      • Court records indicate Costanza did in fact enter a guilty plea on January 27, 2000. The Court later entered a “conditional discharge order and additional conditions order” disposition for the case
    • 2000 Home foreclosure in Boone County
      • Court records indicate Costanza’s home was in fact foreclosed on, with the Court confirming the sale and ordering possession on July 19, 2000.
    • 2000 Completes Chapter 7 bankruptcy filed in 1996 as Chapter 13
      • Court records indicate Costanza did file for Chapter 13 bankruptcy in 1996, converted it to a Chapter 7, which was later finalized by the Court on January 3, 2000.
    • 2007 Pleads guilty to drunk driving in Winnebago County
      • Court records indicate Costanza did in fact enter a guilty plea of DUI on February 27, 2007. The Court later entered a “court supervision” disposition of the case.
    • 2008 Wisconsin DOI denied insurance license for false application
      • According to the Wisconsin Commissioner of Insurance’ Annual report (see page 41), Costanza did in fact have his license denied for 31 days, based on allegations of failing to disclose previous criminal convictions on an insurance license application and failing to disclose a company termination for allegations of misconduct. November 2008.
    • 2010 Indiana DOI fines him $1500 false application & revokes insurance license
    • 2011 Terminated from RMS Service Group for misappropriating company funds
      • According to an RMS Service Group letter obtained through a FOIA request of a state agency, dated January 27, 2011, Costanza was in fact terminated for the reason(s) listed in the letter, pertaining to financial transactions.
    • 2012 Answers fraudulently again on Illinois DOI license renewal application
    • 2014 Illinois DOI investigates numerous complaints by insurance customers, past terminations, criminal history, unlawful fund withdrawals, and fines & discipline from Wisconsin and Indiana (IL-14-HR-0482 & IN-934-AG10-8031-135)
    • 2014 Illinois DOI revokes insurance business license for major agency violations
    • 2015 Illinois DOI disciplines and fines him $30,000.00 for multiple repeat violations

We cannot allow a repeat criminal like Mr. Costanza to defraud our village like he has defrauded his creditors, customers, past employers, and the Wisconsin, Indiana, and Illinois Departments of Insurance. What else has he done to us?

      • According to Costanza’s letters and documents sent to him by the Wisconsin Commissioner of Insurance’s office, the state defines a “crime” as any misdemeanor, felony, or military offense (except traffic citations). the state defines “convicted” as having been found guilty, a plea of guilty or novo contender, or having been given probation, a suspended sentence, or a fine (see page 10).
      • Within those documents, he says the claim on his termination from Liberty Insurance was looked at by the Illinois department and unemployment office and was closed in his favor (page 11), he also says the disorderly conduct was not supposed to be on the record, and he received supervision for a returned check (page 12). He also talked about the issue with his van on pages 5 and 6.

As for all of the other complaints of comments, posts on social media, and personal distribution of the flyer, we cannot comment as we know of none of those and they were not included as Exhibits in this Complaint.

We emailed Plaintiff (to three of his known email address) and asked for comments to specific questions. As of this publication he has not responded.

10Costanza Complaint 2021


Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on print


  • Cynthia
    Posted at 12:50h, 26 October Reply

    This is a perfect example of how uninformed the voters in Illinois really are. That this man could be elected to office in the first place is classic Illinois.

  • Walter
    Posted at 20:42h, 26 October Reply

    In civil cases, the plaintiff has the burden of proving his case by a preponderance of the evidence. A “preponderance of the evidence” and “beyond a reasonable doubt” are different standards, requiring different amounts of proof.
    Sounds like an uphill battle for the plaintiff.

  • Jack Tarleton
    Posted at 10:37h, 27 October Reply

    John, in addition to the CPA, there’s good old Rule 237 which can result in an attorney fee award as a sanction for false pleading. This dude is likely to end up paying his own lawyer bucks to write that 40-page novelette, and the other attorney fees for having to respond to it. Looks like a summary judgment case if the information you have is accurate.

  • Clint
    Posted at 21:10h, 02 November Reply

    It appears the”Loser” had his record caught in the glass cookie jar. Poster boy for deflection and denial.

  • Your Full Name
    Posted at 19:06h, 12 November Reply

    John, are you really defending this scum?

    really? credibility score takes a hit….

  • CantStandYa
    Posted at 20:46h, 30 November Reply

    Typical politician. Gets caught and blames everyone else.

Post A Comment