Copyright 2024 All Rights Reserved.

May 17, 2024

Shelby County Sheriff – Years Of Malfeasance Fixed –

By Kirk Allen & John Kraft

On July 3, 2022

Shelby Co. (ECWd)

Former Sheriff Koonce appears to be the focal point of more problems in Shelby County than we have seen anywhere, but there is hope.

Law Enforcement Committee minutes reflect Koonce would be accepting applications for Auxiliary deputies in the very near future. “His goal is to have 11 auxiliary to match the 11 patrol deputies currently on the roster. Sheriff Koonce reported he predicts a startup cost of $1400.00 to provide each of the new 11 Auxiliary with 1 shirt and 1 pair of pants, with all other equipment for the unit being provided by themselves.”.

For starters, Koonce had no budget for Auxiliary deputies. (2015 Budget at this link)

He also had no authority to have auxiliary deputies without the advice and consent of the county board who also sets the number.

(55 ILCS 5/3-6012) (from Ch. 34, par. 3-6012)
    Sec. 3-6012. Auxiliary deputies. The sheriff of any county in Illinois may, with the advice and consent of the county board appoint auxiliary deputies in such number as the county board shall from time to time deem necessary. However, such number of appointed auxiliary deputies shall not increase after January 1, 1982 if vacancies exist within the certified ranks of the department. Such auxiliary deputies shall not be regular appointed deputies pursuant to Section 3-6008, nor shall they be members of a county police department established pursuant to Divisions 3-7 and 3-8.  (Source: P.A. 86-962.)

It turns out that Koonce not only had auxiliary deputies without board approval, but went well beyond the 11 he claimed he would have.  We requested the roster of all auxiliary deputies since Koonce took office and the numbers are staggering in light of the fact there was never any board approval, which means there was a huge liability during that time if something were to happen to them or to others by them.

Auxiliary Deputy roster by year (click here for complete Roster during Koonce Terms in office)

  • 2015* – 18 Names on the Roster (* no date on the first page of records provided)
  • 2016 – 20 Names on the Roster
  • 2017 – 20 Names on the Roster
  • 2018 – 19 Names on the Roster
  • 2019 – 11 Names on the Roster
  • 2020 – 13 Names on the Roster

A request for minutes from the County Board setting the number of auxiliary deputies turned up nothing.  Shortly after that response a set of records was provided which they thought set the number, but turns out those records only expose more malfeasance dating clear back to 1975.  The minutes report there were 10 auxiliary deputies “working now.”  The minutes reflect a request for permission to uniform ten men as auxiliary police officers.  By all indications in the records, the vote was to grant permission to clothe ten men, not set the number of auxiliary deputies at 10 as was believed to be the case when the records were provided.

Upon clearing up the fact those minutes did not set the number as believed, we were welcomed with an email from current Sheriff Brian McReynolds.

“As of today 06/23/22 Shelby County Sheriff’s Office Auxiliary Deputies have been disbanded.

I believe under current statues and training demands it would be difficult to properly manage an Auxiliary force.  However if in the future it appears to be needed I would approach the Board for advice and consent to appoint a number deemed necessary.”

Thank You
Sheriff Brian McReynolds”

We commend Sheriff McReynolds for doing the right thing.  Unlike many elected officials who want to continue operating as they always have just because they think they can, McReynolds clearly read the law and knew the proper steps had not been followed and did the right thing by disbanding the program, and recognized the proper way to implement it in the future.

If we had more officials willing to simply follow the law as McReynolds did we would see far more things getting fixed in this state.

Thank you Sheriff McReynolds.



Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on print


1 Comment
  • Justice Seeker
    Posted at 15:50h, 03 July

    The county board for years has failed to do their job. They continue to say they can’t tell a department head what to do. Any board member who does not know their statutory duty should resign immediately. The board is too afraid to ask questions of anyone other than the one they hate. The one they hate is the one asking the questions and following law. Shelby County taxpayers deserve better and they deserve a state’s attorney who will ask the questions and seek truth not cover up.