Copyright 2024 All Rights Reserved.

May 18, 2024

McHenry County-Political Influence vs Justice

By Kirk Allen & John Kraft

On May 15, 2018

McHenry Co. (ECWd) –

When we see such clear evidence of wrongdoing with taxpayer money and no one is charged, more often than not, local relationships hold the clues as to why we have little accountability at the local level. That old saying you don’t crap where you eat has become the standard in Illinois and Mchenry County appears to fall in line with the rest of the state.

Most know Judges talk, State’s Attorneys talk, Lawyers talk, Village and City Mayors talk. The politics of Illinois knows no bounds when it comes to matters of influence peddling and protecting the status quo through all that talking behind the scenes. The key to breaking this chain, known as the Combine in Illinois, is exposure.

Connect the dots as it relates to Algonquin Township:

  • Judge Micheal Chmiel – Current Civil Judge in McHenry County – After graduating law school clerked for a Bankruptcy Court in Rockford. In 2002, started his own firm and a large part of his practice involved local government law.
  • Bob Miller – Former Algonquin Road District Commissioner, a personal friend of Judge Chmiel with whom he had a long-standing political, professional, and social relationship with, to include having Chmiel’s law firm represent the Road District.
  • Miller and Judge Chmiel served together on the Salvation Army Board
  • Rebecca Lee – Local attorney, daughter of Bob Miller -A native of McHenry County started her career as an Assistant McHenry County State’s Attorney. -Asked Judge Chmiel for an emergency special hearing for her arrested Uncle in 2007.  Judge Chmiel later reprimanded for an appearance of impropriety related to that emergency hearing. 
  • Karen Lukasik – Algonquin Township Clerk, ran for office with Bob Miller support – Filed Bankruptcy in 2004 – Micheal Chmiel of Chmiel & Matuszewich represented her in that bankruptcy.
  • James Kelley – former Assistant State’s Attorney, McHenry County, Senior Litigation Attorney for 8 years. In that role, represented the McHenry County Board, the McHenry County Sheriff, Recorder of Deeds, the McHenry County Clerk, Planning and Development Department, and Transportation Department.  Algonquin Township Attorney, also named in Bankruptcy final report in 2007 of Karen Lukasik.
  • Every Village and City Mayor endorsed Robert Miller for Road District Commissioner.

All of these people have an influence to some degree in the politics of McHenry County, with maybe the exception of Karen Lukasik who is simply unable to manage either her own finances or the office of Township Clerk.  With so many dots connected so close to Robert Miller, isn’t it fair to ask, what kind of influence do all these people have when it comes to possible criminal indictments against Robert Miller and others at the Algonquin Township Road District?  How many conversations have taken place over the last year on what should or should not happen on this matter?  Oh to be that fly on the wall!

We contend that this entire Algonquin mess is too politically sensitive for local prosecution.   When alleged criminal acts began to surface, the local Sheriff refused to investigate due to his political connections with those who would be investigated.  We understand the State Police were of little assistance due to resource allocation.  That leaves the State’s Attorney’s office to become both investigating agency and prosecutor.  A line that can only be walked with a very limited exception on this type of case. Cross that line and the whole case gets thrown out.

Prosecution of public corruption can be a two-edged sword.  On one hand, you’re the citizen’s hero for protecting the taxpayer while on the other hand, you become the arch enemy of the political party of those charged, a sure self-destruction of future political favor if that is your own party, which in this case it is.  Putting local politics and friendship aside may well be one of the hardest things a prosecutor has to do.

Considering there is yet another civil court filing alleging Breach of Fiduciary Duty, Conversion, Constructive Fraud, and an Accounting, it is clear there are legal minds that see the same thing we are seeing.

If the local State’s Attorney selects to use his prosecutorial discretion and not prosecute, we predict he will be a one-term State’s Attorney.  We also predict if he does move forward with a truly aggressive prosecution, it will be a game changer to his political career as well as the career’s of numerous other corrupt public figures in McHenry County……… maybe the Crystal Lake Park Board members giving themselves compensation in violation of the law?

Our work is funded entirely thru donations and we ask that you consider donating at the below link.


Share on facebook
Share on twitter
Share on print


  • Karen
    Posted at 16:01h, 16 May

    What a shame Mchenry County,IL. has been ripped off by Robert Miller who lives within a mile of my house. Miller rd by Miller rd sign on his drive way. I’m sure Cary,residents have paid for that sign also.

  • Turbo
    Posted at 21:04h, 16 May

    Judge Chmeil is dishonest and corrupt. Should have been removed.He is on for to be a judge.

  • Turbo
    Posted at 21:09h, 16 May

    On fit to be a judge. This judge and Miller should be room made in jail

  • Turbo
    Posted at 21:50h, 16 May

    Case no. 17ch435 will be dismissed due corruption in the Mchenry court. This case is playing musical chairs. From Sullivan to Chmial, Caldwell, Sullivan to Meyer. All friends of Miller. Caldwell retirement is a mystery, was he forced to retired. Meyer will rule in favor of Miller , because is corrupt. Meyer is the one that lost a gun in the post office. Should have gone to jail for violation of federal law.
    No guns allow in federal buildings, he should know the law. He is above the law, has connections. Others for same violation have done jail time.